Had a fantastic time in LA, really good to connect with people from all over the world. For the pictures of the event see the ones that Paul Roberts has posted on: http://www.proberts1.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/index.html
It struck me once again how different Emergent US is to what is happening in the emerging church in the UK. Emergent US is essentially a brand and it seems to be working in that context, however, I’d have major hesitations if that brand were exported to the UK. I also found out that the brand trademark is owned by Rupert Murdock; another good reason to avoid it!
There’s a bit of controversy at the moment regarding some forthcoming criticism of Emergent US from Don Carson. I can fully understand that his criticism is hurtful to people involved in the movement, but on the other side of the equation I want to say does it really matter? A child wants praise off their parent but there also comes a time when a child needs to mature and accept the criticism, listen to it, evaluate it and judge it accordingly. It is then a question of what we do with our evaluation, do we go running back to the parent and try to change their mind or do we accept that the parent is part of the past culture and has a worldview that is blinkered by that culture.
I would listen to the criticism, take it on the chin and then forget about it because quite simply it doesn’t really matter what Don Carson thinks…
My question out of this is how indicative is this of the maturity of the movement? I think that there are some fantastic people in Emergent US but question why the criticism is causing so much pain. I wonder if part of the reason is that emergent US seems to have far closer ties with the evangelical wing of the church and the criticism is coming from an evangelical. Whereas the emerging church in the UK is broader and will be criticised by catholics as not being sacramental enough, evangelicals for not being biblically based and liberals for being too mission focused….I’m polarizing, but my point is that when you are from a broad church you’re used to living with difference and celebrating diversity.
I'm off on holiday now...